Before I begin, a brief word on what it is I'm actually doing. Someone used the term critic to refer to what it is I'm planning, and it's no secret that there is rarely love for critics in the creative community.
First off, I am not trying to be a critic, at least by the popular definition. In modern vocabulary, a critic is someone who expresses a NEGATIVE opinion of something. However, a critic is simply a person who states THEIR opinion on the merit of something (ie. movies). Occasionally my opinions may be negative, but just as often they may be positive.
Secondly, people seem to have this idea that critics are only professionally paid people. Every time you walk out of a movie, turn to a friend or date and exclaim 'That was the coolest movie ever, did you see those special effects?' or 'Meh, the effects were awesome but that was literally just the storyline from Dances with Wolves' (The response I was given from a friend about Cameron's Avatar), every time someone states their opinion they are being a critic: someone who states their opinion. I'm not getting paid for this, I'm just speaking as a friend on the interwebs, explaining my opinion. Am I always right? No. Do I share the same opinion with everyone else? No. Do I enjoy it? Yep. And so that's why I'm doing it.
XxXxX
Edge of Tomorrow
Summary: The story follows a man forced to fight a war he wanted to run from. The soldier becomes stuck in a time loop, allowing him to grow, both in strength and knowledge of his alien enemy as each time cycle is reset.
Main Actors: Tom Cruise, Emily Blunt
Genre: Apocalyptic, Alien, Mech Warfare, Time Travel
Rating: C (Worth Seeing At Least Once)
BEWARE - SPOILERS POSSIBLE - BEWARE
Personal Review: This is what happens when gamers who can't decide why kind of movie they want to watch decide to make a movie! In a world brought to its knees by an alien lifeform, after suffering great losses the humans begin fighting back with exoskeletonal suits equipped with only the most explosive weapons, one man forced onto the front lines against his will gains the ability to reset the level, I mean world every time he dies until the point he can kill the final boss, I mean alien. I don't think I've seen a movie that's combined all these elements before so this is one instance where the sum is greater than the parts and that makes it worth it to watch at least once.
Acting: C
Tom Cruise is Tom Cruise. If you've seen one of his movies then you've already seen his character. He does a good job, but lets face it, when he is on screen there really are no other characters. (Of course we could chalk that up to the writers not his acting, so I gave him a solid performance C!)
As for the other actors, they didn't really get enough screen time to be good or bad in my opinion. No one was openly bad, which settles them all into the average C category. Good job guys! (Once again, writers fault I suppose, not theirs).
Writing: D+
D+ does feel kinda harsh, but here's why. First off, like I said before, they took well-worn ideas and combined them in a new way (at least that I can think of, could be wrong!) and I did like that. And as an occasional gamer I got a kick out of the concept of a game in real life (resetting the world when you fail a level).
But! Beyond the concept the movie just fell somewhat short. Okay, to start with there was exactly one character in this story. 'But Tim,' you may be saying to your computer as if it were me. 'Don't most stories revolve around one characters journey?' They do, you are quite correct, but where this movie differs is that most stories have side characters who help move the story further and provide depth. This movie didn't really.
Due to the format they used for the time travel our main character is the only one with a memory of what had already happened. Which means there really couldn't be any development in any of the other characters (really there was only one other, the bad-ass warrior babe) because throughout the whole movie they HAD to be the same as when the movie started.
So on the one hand, you might say the authors did a good job keeping true to the form of time travel where no character except the time traveler changed. But on the other the authors did try to give them depth. All or nothing, I dislike writing that tries to have it both ways! So there were watered down attempts at depth, a car ride in which their past is discovered, Cruises character falling for a girl he'd known for many cycles despite the fact that the girl knew he for a day and a shared kiss. It was forced.
The other main contention I had of course was with the time travel. (First, let me mention that I LOVE time travel stuff because it's fun to pick apart. Inconsistencies is the bread and butter of time travel.) Okay, so there's the main alien 'brain' resetting the day any time one of its nerve centers (the blue aliens) is killed. The main character gets joined into this system so any time HE dies the world is reset. First off, this has happened to other humans, the Bad-ass warrior babe being an example. Second, according to her if the blood is diluted through a transfusion the power is lost. Third, there must be more that one nerve center at any time because even after the main character gets the power to reset time we still run into at least 2 of the alien nerve centers.
This question was actually posed by one of my friends. What happens if two people kill a nerve center at the same time? Or if someone has the ability and someone else, somewhere else kills a different nerve center. Whose world is reset? Would the second guy lose the ability since his day was reset after the first guy died?
What determines the reset? For our main character is was when he woke up the day before the attack that led to him getting the power. Why the day before and not the moment he was joined into the alien's ability? (The answer is because he was dying when he got the power, and there's no movie there). And then after he kills the 'brain' he goes back even further? First off if the alien is the reason that time is being reset if he kills is, why isn't that ability lost to him? And what is determining these save points?
And the final bit, when he is storming the Louvre where the alien brain is hiding they crash a freaken plane and not a single alien shows up until five minutes later, after they've had time to gather survivors, make a plan, and restart a plan which had just crashed landed before the alien soldiers appear. Lucky huh? But wouldn't you think a super intelligent alien whose greatest weakness is the defensiveness of its 'brain' would lead it to have some sort of protection? I mean they all but strolled up to it and poked it before the alien did anything to stop them.
The alien was a cool concept and looked pretty awesome, but I feel like the writers didn't really put much thought into it.
Visual: B+
Okay, so I'm a sucker for advance technology. The exoskeletons were freaken awesome and I need one, or ten. Stark Industries, get right on that! The aliens were also pretty slick with their spinning and tentacles and exploding bodies with acid blood. And of course the man gamer eye candy of a bad-ass warrior babe, who instead of fighting with a guy like LITERALLY EVERYONE ELSE has a giant knife. Yep.
Audio: C
Really, I don't have much to say on this point. Nothing special in my opinion but I'm usually more focused on the writing aspect that the audio aspect unless the audio somehow really plays into the story. (Thank you Inception and Alien)
Now hopefully you've watched it before reading the spoilers so in the comment section below tell me what you thought of it. Did you have other questions than I did. Think you have answers to my questions that I miss? Just have a totally different opinion than I did? I'd love to hear about it, and if this ever picked up steam, I might even do a midweek post where I repost the commenters opinions and respond to their questions!